Criticism of transformational leadership

Similarly to transformational leaders, inspirational leaders enthuse and arouse others both emotionally and intellectually. This is an effective way to communicate better to their subordinates and followers. Retrieved March 17,from http: It appears to a be a form of leadership well-suited to these current times characterized by uncertainty, global turbulence and Criticism of transformational leadership instability.

Transformational leaders guide followers by providing them with a sense of meaning and challenge. Simmons was a transformational leader who herself attributed her own successes to her kindergarten teacher, Ms Ida Mae Henderson, who had advised her she could do anything in her heart she set out to achieve Chekwa, Some leaders may have narcissistic tendencies, thriving on power and manipulation.

A leader who fails to communicate this will probably fail.

The leader tries to obtain agreement from members on the expected goals and the payoffs for task accomplishments. Introduction Leaders are not necessarily elected formally, provided that the aspirant leader can guide followers and align their efforts toward the achievement of a common goal Goffee and Jones, they can become accepted as leaders.

This becomes more problematic where there is considerable either physical or social distance between leader and followers.

Transformational Leadership

While the classical approach speaks of discipline, transformational leadership speaks of persuasion. Charismatic leaders have exceptional abilities to influence their followers, they are strong role models and the followers want to emulate their behavior.

Transformational Leadership Theory

According to Burns Transformational and transactional leadership: In general, the model of compensation and performance evaluation is a form of transactional leadership model.

Their vision is so compelling that they know what they want from every interaction. In his view transformational leaders should give moral uplift to their followers. Challenges in Details Although transformational leadership model has benefits like having a vision and long-term plans, critics say that these can leave details out of the picture which can have a negative impact on the organization.

Similarly, Yukl believes leaders build the confidence of their followers, either by sending out motivational messages or by creating a positive emotional atmosphere.

10 Disadvantages of Transformational Leadership

Public recognition of achievements and successful shared initiatives might help serve these ends. For example, in an educational context, a school principal or department head could also visit classrooms regularly and encourage others to do the same to better gauge collective requirements ERIC, Searching for African American transformational leaders.

Journal of Applied Psychology, 89 5pp. If followers begin to feel that their part is not important, that they are cogs in a machine, they will lose interest. However, any sign that the leader manipulates the followers or has a hidden agenda will destroy the trust that is necessary for this style of leadership to be effective.

Second, it is important to inspire a shared vision, seeking broad input, and encouraging everyone to think of a new and better future. Not Always Effective Transformational leadership style can motivate followers or individuals and even uplift the morale of people but this style is not applicable all the time.

The Trouble With Transformational Leadership

The vision is created based on collective interests rather than the interests of a leader and so becomes a focal point Northouse, ; Tucker and Russell, The leaders act as role models that followers seek to emulate. Servant leaders consciously desist from using their positional power unless really required.

This example however represents a slightly different conceptualisation of transformational leadership, leaving the question remaining: This implies establishing a fair process of performance evaluation and making sure it is effective and well received by he subordinates.

It is also concerned with transforming organisational performance either from poor to satisfactory performance or from acceptable to excellent Bass and Riggio, ; Mullins, ; Pawar, ; Tucker and Russell, If a particular transformational leader is unaware of this, these changes will not take place since subordinates are thought to still having the same views with the management.

Within educational environments teachers are more likely to collaborate and are held to be more likely to have positive attitudes to school improvement and to new forms of instructional behaviour as a result of transformational leadership ERIC, Inspiring a shared vision will also be achieved through coaching and conscious role modeling strategies.

Can Result to Wrong Decisions Since transformational leaders, say, of nations can stimulate the minds of their followers, they can make these people agree and supportive o f the plans and actions of the government. In the end, they will be tired and dissatisfied because they will feel that they are taken advantage of.

Private notes of congratulation to successful followers can also help foster self-confidence ERIC, Deontological ethics give greatest consideration to upholding promises and maintaining universal values or principles see Israel and Hay for a full discussion.

From transactional to transformational leadership: They both had a burning personal conviction that their goals for their nations were the right and best goals. Servant leaders view continual development of subordinates as vital to health of the organization.

Criticisms of Transformational Leadership Theory Transformational leadership makes use of impression management and therefore lends itself to amoral self promotion by leaders The theory is very difficult to e trained or taught because it is a combination of many leadership theories.Table 1.

Dimensions of Transformational Leadership. Nevertheless, it is clear that general understandings of transformational leadership are dominated by acceptance of the four dimensions set out in the left-hand column of Table 1 (see, for example, Stone, Russell & Patterson ()).

A critique of transformational leadership: Moral, professional and contingent dimensions of leadership within public services organizations Show all authors Graeme Currie.

Transformational Vs Transactional Leadership. Criticism of Transformational Leadership. Potential to be abused: Transformational leadership’s high effectiveness in leader’s vision makes it undemocratic; the leader’s purpose is largely unchallenged, thus liable to be misused by the leader.

There is plenty of historical evidence. A critique of Transformational Leadership theory Introduction This paper assesses the main characteristics of the criticisms which are made against transformational leadership (TL) theory. Particular emphasis is placed on those arguments which question the entire theoretical basis of TL on the.

According to, transformational leadership is a leadership style in which a leader identifies the need for change, creates a vision for guiding the change through inspiration. Transformational leadership can be found at all levels of management.

Transformational leaders are visionary, inspiring, daring, risk-takers, and thoughtful thinkers.

Criticism of transformational leadership
Rated 4/5 based on 5 review